Voltaire, Candide

October 25, 2023

Voltaire is advocating philosophical skepticism.

Pangloss embodies the optimistic notion that ultimate reality can be known by reason, and Martin embodies the pessimistic notion that ultimate reality defies a rational accounting and can be known only through a manichaeistic mythology.

Cacambo embodies the notion that one cannot know whether or not ultimate reality can be proved by reason.

From the text:

"I do not know," answered the worthy man, "and I have not known the name of any Mufti, nor of any Vizier. I am entirely ignorant of the event you mention; I presume in general that they who meddle with the administration of public affairs die sometimes miserably, and that they deserve it; but I never trouble my head about what is transacting at Constantinople; I content myself with sending there for sale the fruits of the garden which I cultivate." ... "I have only twenty acres," replied the old man; "I and my children cultivate them; our labour preserves us from three great evils—weariness, vice, and want."

"Let us work," said Martin, "without disputing; it is the only way to render life tolerable."

"All that is very well," answered Candide, "but let us cultivate our garden."

From SEP entry on Voltaire

His famous conclusion in Candide, for example, that optimism was a philosophical chimera produced when dialectical reason remains detached from brute empirical facts owed a great debt to his Newtonian convictions.

His alternative offered in the same text of a life devoted to simple tasks with clear, tangible, and most importantly useful ends was also derived from the utilitarian discourse that Newtonians also used to justify their science.